AQ. initial [s] plus voiceless stops became voiceless spirants; [sp-|st-|sk-] > [ɸ-|θ-|x-]
An initial s followed by a voiced stop developed into a voiceless spirant of the same quality: sp, st, sk > f (or ꝑ), þ, χ (IPA [f] or [ɸ], [θ], [x]). A similar change occurred in Sindarin. Tolkien discussed this sound change in both the Outline of Phonetic Development (OP1) from the 1940s and the Outline of Phonology (OP2) from the 1950s:
[Initial] sky, skw became simplified to [χy, χw] whence Q hy, hw, identical with the products of khy, khw: see above. The same development was common in the case of sp, st, sk which thus became [ꝑ, þ, x] > f, th (s), h initially (OP1: PE19/30).
[Initial] sp, st, sk. For these initial groups a development to f, þ, h identical with that of ph, th, kh but probably coalescing with these only at the spirantal stage, is well evidenced, & occurs in many words and stems. It is improbable that sp, st, sk ever became aspirates. They more likely reached the stage f, þ, h through long spirants ff, þþ, χχ soon simplified (OP2: PE19/78).
In the 1930s, Tolkien described similar developments for initial sky, skw, but in the 1950s he decided these combinations did not occur initially in Primitive Elvish (PE19/78 note #51). The Quenya phonetic developments were a bit different than in Sindarin/Noldorin, where it seems that st- > sþ- > þ-, but in Quenya st- > þþ- > þ-. As indicated by the quotes above, it seems this sound change was after aspirates became voiceless spirants, but Tolkien seems to have vacillated on whether it was before or after [ɸ], [β] became [f], [v], so whether sp- > ꝑ or f is unclear.
Attested examples are quite numerous in the 1930s, 50s and 60s, and some a few examples appear as early as the 1920s, such as: ᴱ✶skantá [> *χanta] > ᴱQ. hanta “blow with an axe” (PE13/147) and ᴱ✶stak+ta [> *þakta] > ᴱQ. sahta- “to split” (PE14/66). It seems plausible the same sound changes applied to the earliest Qenya of the 1910s but there are no clear examples.
References ✧ PE19/78, 84
Order (02100)
After | 02000 | syllabic initial [s] became [is] | ||
Before | 02300 | [x] unvoiced following [j], [w] | ||
Before | 03400 | unstressed medial long vowels shortened | ᴹ✶farāyā́ > fárăyā > ᴹQ. farea | PE22/111 |
Related
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/78 (sp > ff > f; initially) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/78 (st > þþ > þ; initially) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/78 (sk > χχ > h; initially) |
Phonetic Rule Examples
skalā > xalā | sk- > x- | ✶skalā > Q. hala | ✧ PE17/184 |
skūna > xūna | sk- > x- | √SKŪ > Q. hūna | ✧ PE17/149 |
skūta- > xūta- | sk- > x- | √SKŪ > Q. húta- | ✧ PE17/149 |
spinde > ɸinde | sp- > ɸ- | √SPIN-ID > Q. findë | ✧ PE17/119 |
spindelē > ɸindelē | sp- > ɸ- | ✶espin-delē > Q. phindele | ✧ PE17/17 |
spindele > ɸindele | sp- > ɸ- | ✶spindilā > Q. findile | ✧ PE17/17 |
spine > ɸine | sp- > ɸ- | √SPIN- > Q. phin- | ✧ PE17/17 |
spine > ɸine | sp- > ɸ- | √SPIN- > Q. fine | ✧ PE17/17 |
star- > θar- | st- > θ- | √STAR > Q. thar | ✧ PE22/133 |
steglō > θeglō | st- > θ- | ✶steglō > thélo > þélo > Q. sélo | ✧ PE19/95 |
stelma > θelma | st- > θ- | √stel > Q. þelma | ✧ WJ/319 |
stenna > θenna | st- > θ- | ✶stenna > thenna > Q. senna | ✧ PE17/185 |
stentā > θentā | st- > θ- | ✶stentā > thenta > Q. senta | ✧ PE17/141 |
ᴹAQ. initial [s] plus voiceless stops became voiceless spirants; [sp-|st-|sk-] > [ɸ-|θ-|x-]
References ✧ PE19/36-37, 41
Order (02200)
After | 02100 | syllabic initial [s] became [is] | ||
Before | 02400 | [x], [s] unvoiced following [j], [w] | ||
Before | 03500 | unstressed medial long vowels shortened | ᴹ✶farāyā́ > fárăyā > ᴹQ. farea | PE22/111 |
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/37 (sp > f; initial) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/37 (st > th; initial) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/38 (sky > hy; initial); PE19/38 (skw > hw; initial); PE19/37 (sk > h; initial) |
Phonetic Rule Examples
skala > xala | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKAL² > ᴹQ. hala | ✧ Ety/SKAL² |
skalja- > xalja- | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKAL¹ > ᴹQ. halya- | ✧ Ety/SKAL¹ |
skalja- > xalja- | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKAL³ > ᴹQ. halya- | ✧ EtyAC/SKAL³ |
skalmā > xalmā | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skalmā > ᴹQ. halma | ✧ EtyAC/SKEL |
skalnā > xalnā | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skalnā > ᴹQ. halda | ✧ Ety/SKAL¹ |
skalna > xalna | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skalnā > ᴹQ. halla | ✧ EtyAC/SKEL |
skarna- > xarna- | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKAR > ᴹQ. harna- | ✧ Ety/SKAR |
skarnā > xarnā | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skarnā > ᴹQ. harna | ✧ Ety/SKAR |
skarwē > xarwē | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skarwē > ᴹQ. harwe | ✧ Ety/SKAR |
skat- > xat- | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKAT > ᴹQ. hat- | ✧ Ety/SKAT |
skelmā > xelmā | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skelmā > ᴹQ. helma | ✧ Ety/SKEL |
skelnā > xelnā | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skelnā > ᴹQ. helda | ✧ Ety/SKEL |
skjapat > xjapat | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skyapat- > ᴹQ. hyapat | ✧ Ety/SKYAP |
skora- > xora- | sk- > x- | ᴹ✶skorā > ᴹQ. hora | ✧ PE22/113 |
skwarin > xwarin | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKWAR > ᴹQ. hwarin | ✧ Ety/SKWAR |
skwarma > xwarma | sk- > x- | ᴹ√SKWAR > ᴹQ. hwarma | ✧ Ety/SKWAR |
spaika > ɸaika | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ√SPAY > ᴹQ. faika | ✧ Ety/SPAY |
spāna > ɸāna | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ√SPAN > ᴹQ. fána | ✧ Ety/SPAN |
spaŋgā > ɸaŋgā | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶spangā > ᴹQ. fanga | ✧ Ety/SPÁNAG |
spanja > ɸanja | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ√SPAN > ᴹQ. fanya | ✧ Ety/SPAN |
spantur > ɸantur | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶Spanturo > ᴹQ. Fantur | ✧ Ety/SPAN |
spara- > ɸara- | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶sparā > ᴹQ. fara- | ✧ PE22/113 |
spāra > ɸāra | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ√SPAR² > ᴹQ. fára | ✧ EtyAC/SPAR² |
sparājā > ɸarājā | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶farāyā́ > fárăyā > ᴹQ. farea | ✧ PE22/111 |
sparma > ɸarma | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ√SPAR² > ᴹQ. farma | ✧ EtyAC/SPAR² |
spinde > ɸinde | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶spindē > ᴹQ. finde | ✧ Ety/SPIN |
spinē > ɸinē | sp- > ɸ- | ᴹ✶spinē > ᴹQ. fine | ✧ Ety/SPIN |
stabnē > θabnē | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stabnē > ᴹQ. samna | ✧ Ety/STAB |
stabnō > θabnō | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stabnō > ᴹQ. samno | ✧ Ety/STAB |
stabrō > θabrō | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stabrō > ᴹQ. sauro | ✧ EtyAC/STAB |
stambē > θambē | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stambē > ᴹQ. sambe | ✧ Ety/STAB |
θanda > θanda | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAN > ᴹQ. sanda | ✧ Ety/STAN |
θaŋgā > θaŋgā | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stangā > ᴹQ. sanga | ✧ Ety/STAG |
θaŋgā > θaŋgā | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAG > ᴹQ. sanga | ✧ PE22/107 |
θaŋgasjandō > θaŋgasjandō | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stangasyandō > ᴹQ. sangahyando | ✧ Ety/SYAD |
θanja > θanja | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAN > ᴹQ. sanya | ✧ Ety/STAN |
θanje > θanje | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAN > ᴹQ. sanye | ✧ Ety/STAN |
θaŋkā > θaŋkā | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stankā > ᴹQ. sanka | ✧ Ety/STAK |
star- > θar- | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAR > ᴹQ. thare | ✧ PE22/112 |
θara > θara | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STAR > ᴹQ. sara | ✧ Ety/STAR |
stegrā > θegrā | st- > θ- | ᴹ✶stegrā > ᴹQ. thḗra | ✧ PE19/46 |
stintā > θintā | st- > θ- | ᴹ√STINTĀ > ᴹQ. sinta | ✧ Ety/STINTĀ |
stugnā > θugnā | st- > θ- | ✶stuknā > Q. thúna | ✧ PE19/86 |
stundo > θundo | st- > θ- | ᴹ√SUD > ᴹQ. sundo | ✧ Ety/SUD |
ᴱQ. initial [s] plus voiceless stops became voiceless spirants; [s{pɸ}-|s{tθ}-|s{kx}-] > [ɸ-|θ-|x-]
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
|
|
> |
|
|
|
> |
|
Phonetic Rule Examples
skampa- > xampa- | sk- > x- | ᴱ√kapa- > skamp- > ᴱQ. hampa- | ✧ PE14/66 |
skanta > xanta | sk- > x- | ᴱ✶skantá > ᴱQ. hanta | ✧ PE13/147 |
skapta- > xapta- | sk- > x- | ᴱ✶skapi̯a- > ᴱQ. hapta- | ✧ PE14/66 |
skend > xend | sk- > x- | ᴱ✶ske-ndá > ᴱQ. hen | ✧ PE13/147 |
staina > θaina | st- > θ- | ᴱ✶stainá > ᴱQ. saina | ✧ PE13/153 |
stakta- > θakta- | st- > θ- | ᴱ✶stak+ta > ᴱQ. sahta | ✧ PE14/66 |