AQ. [z] and [ð] assimilated to following [r], [l]; [{zð}r|{zð}l] > [rr|ll]
In cases where they did not undergo other changes such as metathesis, the primitive combinations dl, dr; sl, sr eventually assimilated to the following liquid and became ll, rr in Quenya. This is not especially surprising, since these combinations first became ðl, ðl (or řl, řr); zl, zr and then both ð, z > r in the Ñoldorin dialect of Quenya, and more generally [rl] became [ll]. However, notes in the Outline of Phonology (OP2) in the 1950s indicate that these sound changes also took place in the Vanyarin dialect:
d became r̃, as between vowels, before w. But dr, dl > rr, ll. In other words, in Quenya, before l, r, w CE d and r became identical ... Note dr, dl > rr, ll also occurred in Vanyarin. The assimilation probably took place at stage řl, řr before V. shift of > z. But sl, sr > zl, zr had same result in V. (and Ñ.) (OP2: PE19/94)
In that case there are three developments of sr: ... (b) after the voicing of intervocalic s > z, sr > zr > rr (such forms were more frequent in N. dialect, since z itself had there become r) ... sl remained as such until the voicing; then zl > ll (OP2: PE19/102).
Since ř, z merged to z instead of ř/r in Vanyarin, the Vanyarin developments indicate the shift to ll, rr took place before the ř/z-mergers of both dialects. Thus, the likeliest phonetic developments were ðl, ðr; zl, zr > ll, rr directly rather than becoming r first.
Conceptual Development: The Early Qenya developments are confused by the fact that ð is part of phonetic inventory of Primitive Elvish in the 1910s and 1920s. Tolkien mentioned no special developments for these combinations in the Qenya Phonology from the 1910s (PE12/24). There are no clear examples of any developments for dl, ðl, dr, ðr in this period, with the possible exception of ᴱ✶nḷdle > ᴱQ. nalle (but here the presence of syllabic ḷ confuses the picture).
Tolkien did describe developments for s > z before l, r, however:
s gave z and then r before l, r ... giving ll, ´r (PE12/19)
Tolkien indicates z vanished before r with compensatory lengthening rather than the pair developing into rr, but there are no clear examples. There is one example of sl [> zl] > ll: ᴱ✶kasla > ᴱQ. kalla “helmet” (PE13/140).
In the Outline of Phonetic Development (OP1) from the 1940s, Tolkien did describe special developments for dl, dr:
[d] became [r] as between vowels, before y, w; dr, dl > rr, ll (OP1: PE19/46).
However in this period, it seems that dr, dl > rr, ll is part of the general trend whereby [d] > [r]. There is an example ᴹ✶nyadrō > ᴹQ. nyarro in The Etymologies (Ety/NYAD). Tolkien likewise mentioned these developments in OP1 for sl but not for sr:
While s was still voiceless sr > sř > ss (similar to developments after stops); but sl appears to have remained as such, and asyllabic. Hence it later became zl > ll (OP1: PE19/49).
There are no examples from the 1930s and 40s that demonstrates sr > ss. However, the sound change sr > rr is mentioned in rejected notes from OP1 (PE19/52 note #119), and there is at least one example of it in this period: ᴹ√SRŌ > ᴹQ. orro- “rise (from ground)”, ᴹQ. orro “up in the air, on high” (PE22/127). The best example of zl > ll is the (archaic) perfect of the verb: ᴹQ. hlik- “creep” derived from the root ᴹ√SLIK: izlīk- > †illīk[ie] (PE22/113).
References ✧ PE17/71; PE19/94, 102
Order (04600)
After | 02900 | voiced stops became spirants except after nasals | ||
After | 04500 | medial [s] often became [z] |
Related
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/94 (dr > rr) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/94 (dl > ll); PE17/71 (-rl- > ll; assimilation) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/94 (zr > rr); PE19/102 (zr > rr) |
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/94 (zl > ll); PE19/102 (zl > ll) |
Phonetic Rule Examples
nizle > nille | zl > ll | √nis > Q. nill- | ✧ VT47/33 |
cazrea > carrea | zr > rr | ✶karrai > Q. carrea | ✧ PE22/159 |
cazrea > carrea | zr > rr | ✶cas-raya > Q. carrea | ✧ VT42/12 |
mizroanwe > mirroanwe | zr > rr | ✶mi-srawanwe > Q. Mirröanwi | ✧ MR/350 |
mizroanwe > mirroanwe | zr > rr | ✶mi-srawanwe > Q. Mirröanwi | ✧ MR/350 |
ᴹAQ. [z] and [ð] assimilated to following [r], [l]; [{zð}r|{zð}l] > [rr|ll]
References ✧ PE19/46, 49
Order (04700)
After | 03000 | voiced stops became spirants except after nasals and liquids | ||
After | 04600 | medial [s] often became [z] |
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
|
|
> |
|
|
|
> |
|
|
|
> |
|
✧ PE19/51 (zl > ll) |
Phonetic Rule Examples
izlīk- > illīk- | zl > ll | ᴹ√SLIK > izlīk- > ᴹQ. †illīk[ie] | ✧ PE22/113 |
sizlikk- > sillikk- | zl > ll | ᴹ√SLIK > sizlikk- > ᴹQ. †sillikk- | ✧ PE22/113 |
ozro > orro | zr > rr | ᴹ√SRŌ > ᴹQ. orro | ✧ PE22/127 |
ozro- > orro- | zr > rr | ᴹ√SRŌ > ᴹQ. orro | ✧ PE22/127 |
njaðrō > njarrō | ðr > rr | ᴹ✶nyadrō > ᴹQ. nyarro | ✧ Ety/NYAD |
ᴱQ. [rl] became [ll]; [rl] > [ll]
Reference ✧ PE12/19
Order ()
After | [z] became [r] |
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
> |
|
Phonetic Rule Examples
karla > kalla | rl > ll | ᴱ✶kasla > ᴱQ. kalla | ✧ PE13/140 |