S. Methedras loc. “Last Peak”
Last peak of the Mist Mountains (LotR/429), explictly translated “Last Peak” in Tolkien’s “Unfinished Index” of The Lord of the Rings (RC/366). This name is a combination of methed “end” and ras(s) “horn”.
Conceptual Development: In Lord of the Rings drafts from the 1940s, this name first appeared as N. Methen Amon (TI/391), later revised to N. Methendol and finally N. Methedras (TI/404). These earlier forms clearly included the Noldorin adjective N. methen “end, final” (Ety/MET). It is possible that this is true of the initial appearance of N. Methedras as well (as suggested by Roman Rausch, EE/2.63), since phonetically the combination [nr] became [ðr], and Tolkien often represented [ð] as “d” in the Lord of the Rings drafts. For example, N. Caradras >> S. Caradhras underwent the same development.
Unlike Caradhras, however, Tolkien never revised this form to **Methedhras. This could have been an oversight, or Tolkien could have reconceived of the initial element as the noun methed “end” seen in Methed-en-Glad, as suggested above (and by David Salo, GS/384).
References ✧ LotR/429; LotRI/Last Mountain, Methedras; RC/366; SA/ras; TII; WRI
Glosses
Elements
methed | “end” | |
ras(s) | “horn” | ✧ SA/ras (ras) |
N. Methedras loc. “Last Peak”
Reference ✧ TI/404
Elements
methen | “end, final” |
rhas | “horn [of both animals and mountains]” |
N. Methendol loc.
Earlier name of Methedras in Lord of the Rings drafts from the 1940s (TI/404), a combination of methen “final” and dôl “hill”.
See S. Methedras for further discussion.
References ✧ TI/404; TII/Methedras
Changes
Elements
methen | “end, final” |
dôl | “head, hill” |