S. Eluréd m. “Heir of Elu (Thingol)”

S. Eluréd, m. “Heir of Elu (Thingol)”

Son of Dior and great-grandson of Elu Thingol (S/234), whose name had the same meaning as his father’s sobriquet Eluchíl “Heir of Elu” (SI/Eluréd). His name is a combination of the name of his great-grandfather Elu and the Bëorian word for “heir”: rêda (PM/369).

Conceptual Development: In Silmarillion drafts from the 1930s, this character was initially named Ilk. Elboron and his brother’s name was Ilk. Elbereth (SM/307). These names were designated Ilkorin in The Etymologies (Ety/BOR, BER) but were rejected, most likely because Tolkien introduced N. Elbereth as a name for Varda (Ety/BARATH). In the narratives of that period, Ilk. Elboron was changed to Eldûn (LR/147 note #42) and so remained in Silmarillion revisions from the 1950s-60s (WJ/351). The name S. Eluréd did not appear until quite late; the etymology given above appeared only in a late essay on “The Problem of Ros” from 1968 (PM/369).

References ✧ PM/369; PMI; SI; SMI/Eldûn, Eluréd

Glosses

Elements

Elu ✧ PM/369
Ed. rêda “heir” ✧ PM/369

N. Eldûn m. “*West-star”

Earlier of Eluréd (LR/147 note #42). Since his brother’s name was Elrûn “*East-star”, this name may be a combination of el “star” and dûn “west”.

See S. Eluréd for further discussion.

References ✧ LR/147; LRI; PMI/Eluréd; SM/325; SMI/Elbereth, Eldûn, Eluréd; WJI/Elboron, Eldún; WRI

Variations

Changes

Elements

el “star”
dûn “west”

Ilk. Elboron m. “*Steadfast Star”

An earlier name for S. Eluréd (LR/147). It appeared in The Etymologies containing Ilk. boron “steadfast”, but the name were rejected, probably at the same time as the name of his brother Ilk. Elbereth (Ety/BOR). Its initial element might be el “star”.

See S. Elurín for further discussion.

References ✧ Ety/BOR; LR/147; LRI; PMI/Eluréd; SM/325; SMI/Elbereth, Eldûn; WJI; WRI

Variations

Changes

Elements

el “star”
boron “steadfast; trusty man, faithful vassal” ✧ Ety/BOR